Arizona Elected Official Stole $38 Million from Santa Cruz County
SHARE

Arizona Elected Official Stole $38 Million from Santa Cruz County

Former_Santa_Cruz_Ariz._Treasurer_Elizaberh_Gutfahr_Sits_in_Court_With_Her_Attorney_After_Pleading_Guilty_to_Stealing_Over_38_Million_From_the_County

Former Santa Cruz County, Ariz., Treasurer Elizabeth Gutfahr sits in a federal court while being tried for embezzling $38 million.

Gutfahr pleaded guilty to three counts and could get up to 35 total years in prison, according to the DOJ press release and her plea agreement. Gutfahr’s sentencing is scheduled for Feb. 6.

Previous Accounting and Real Estate Experience

Gutfahr had experience as an accountant and worked for a real estate company before being elected treasurer in January 2013, according to the indictment. Once elected, Gutfahr became the signer of the county’s Chase checking and savings accounts and was tasked with collecting real and property taxes.

As_Santa_Cruz_County_Treasurer_Elizabeth_Gutfahr_was_responsible_for_maintaining_the_countys_bank_accounts_and_has_been_a_signer_on_those_accounts_since_Jan_8_2013
As Santa Cruz County Treasurer, Elizabeth Gutfahr was responsible for maintaining the county’s bank accounts and has been a signer on those accounts since Jan. 8, 2013, according to an indictment obtained by The Daily Muck.

Multiple Business Banking Accounts

Gutfahr had a real estate license from 2008 to 2012 under the business name “Rico Real Estate and Consulting” and opened a business account at Wells Fargo under the same business name on Feb. 3, 2011, according to the indictment. The business, however, was never registered with the Arizona Corporation Commission, nor was it assigned an Employer Identification Number (EIN) with the IRS. This account was closed in March 2024.

On May 24, 2019, Gutfahr created the Double D Cattle Company of Santa County, LLC, and opened a business account at Wells Fargo Bank under that name, according to the indictment. On Oct. 15, 2019, Gutfahr created the Rancho San Cayetano, LLC, which served as a horse boarding facility. Gutfahr’s personal residence was there, and she opened a business checking account for the company.

On Jan. 29, 2024, Gutfahr opened a BMO business checking account under Rio Rico Consulting, as detailed in the indictment.

Transferred Money from County to Business Bank Accounts

Between March 13, 2014, and March 28, 2024, Gutfahr initiated around 187 wire transfers from the county’s Chase Bank accounts to her Wells Fargo and BMO accounts, according to the indictment. The amount stolen from Santa Cruz County was more than $38 million.

Prosecutors_say_Gutfahr_made_187_wire_transfers_from_Santa_Cruz_County_funds_into_her_personal_bank_account_stealing_more_than_38_million
Prosecutors say Gutfahr made 187 wire transfers from Santa Cruz County funds into her personal bank account, stealing more than $38 million.

Gutfahr sent most of the wires to her Wells Fargo account until she opened the BMO account in January 2024, according to the indictment. Gutfahr also circumvented the two-step approval process, where the Chief Deputy Treasurer would initiate a wire transfer using a computer token assigned to the Chief Deputy. Gutfahr could skip this step by using the token herself and then approving the transactions.

Even_though_all_transactions_regarding_county_funds_had_a_two-person_approval_process_Gutfahr_was_able_to_subvert_it_by_fraudulently_using_credentials_assigned_to_the_Chief_Deputy_Treasurer
Even though all transactions regarding county funds had a two-person approval process, Gutfahr was able to subvert it by fraudulently using credentials assigned to the Chief Deputy Treasurer, according to the indictment.

False Claims and Records

Gutfahr tried to justify her use of the Chief Deputy’s token by falsely claiming that the Wells Fargo account was a savings account that earned interest for the county, according to the indictment. Gutfahr also made false statements on reports to make it look as if the spending was legitimate and, from 2018 to 2023, inflated cash expenditures and reconciliation balances to conceal the theft.

Around 97% of all deposits into Gutfahr’s Wells Fargo account were money taken from the Santa Cruz County account to enrich herself, the indictment details. Gutfahr used the money to purchase expensive real estate properties, writing checks and withdrawing funds from her Wells Fargo and later her BMO accounts to complete the purchases.

Didn’t Pay Taxes on Stolen Money

Gutfahr also didn’t claim the money she stole between 2014 and 2024 in her tax returns, so she owes $13,143,526.00 in back taxes to the IRS, according to the indictment.

Jessika Saunders
Jessika Saunders is a journalist with a passion for politics. When she isn't writing, she enjoys the Arizona weather and teaches virtual fitness classes. Jessika also writes fiction novels and hopes to become a published author in the future.
Reprint and Permissions
The Daily Muck grants permission to other publications and individuals to use our articles, images, and content, provided that proper credit is given by linking back to the original source at https://dailymuck.com. To request additional permissions or for any inquiries, please contact us at info@dailymuck.com.

Weekly Muck

Join the mission and subscribe to our newsletter. In exchange, we promise to fight for justice.

By signing up, you confirm that you are over the age of 16 and agree to receive occasional promotional offers for programs that support The Daily Muck’s journalism. You may unsubscribe or adjust your preferences at any time. You can read our Privacy Policy here.

Weekly
Muck

Join the mission and subscribe to our newsletter. In exchange, we promise to fight for justice.

By signing up, you confirm that you are over the age of 16 and agree to receive occasional promotional offers for programs that support The Daily Muck’s journalism. You may unsubscribe or adjust your preferences at any time. You can read our Privacy Policy here